EMI share options: How to incentivise key staff

As an incentive that small to medium-sized companies can offer to key employees, EMI share options have proven to be very effective. They can be a tax-effective and mutually beneficial agreement between a company’s custodians (board of directors), owners (shareholders) and those key employees that add value to the business. With years of experience in dealing in the legal matters of businesses of all sizes, we are highlighting corporate processes that many of our clients over the years have used to their advantage to increase the value of their business and the value of their shares.

With our expert advice, you will be better equipped to avoid legal pitfalls and make the decisions that will benefit your business the most. In this first entry in our corporate advice series, we will be discussing enterprise management incentive (EMI) schemes.

An EMI share option plan enables persons granted share options with an opportunity to participate in the share ownership – or more typically, on the sale of the company’s issued shares. EMI share options are targeted at owner-managed-businesses (OMBs) and other small to medium enterprises (SMEs).

To qualify to grant EMI options, a company must:

  • be an independent trading company with a qualifying trade;
  • have gross assets not exceeding £30 million at the time of grant;
  • have less than 250 full-time employees (or its equivalent); and
  • have a UK-based permanent establishment.

The benefits of EMI share options

Typically, EMI share options will be granted to employees who add real value to the business, and whose departure would hurt the company’s future.

The reason why existing shareholders may consider granting EMI share options depend from case to case, but include:

  • Golden Handcuffs for key employees allow them to have a share in any future share sale price, providing they remain at the company until the remaining shareholders sell.
  • To reward long-term highly valued service without having to change the remuneration structure of the workforce, or impacting cash flow.
  • As part of a recruitment package to compensate an incoming key employee for any EMI or other share options lost due to changing employers.
  • As a lure to motivate an incoming key employee to drive up the value of the company.
  • To widen the company’s shareholder base.
  • As a tempt for a key employee to consider a management buy-out (MBO) in the future.
  • For the tax benefits available – any uplift in value from the option grant date (at market value as agreed with HMRC) to the sale date will be liable to capital gains tax (CGT) for which the option-holder should qualify for Entrepreneurs’ Relief (ER).
  • To give potentially significant value to key employees without their having to fund any purchase of shares in the company.

The process for a company considering EMI

When a company’s Board of directors assesses that an EMI share option scheme may be of value both to the company and to the company’s existing shareholders, they will need to convene a meeting of all shareholders (or their representatives).

The granting of share options has the effect of “diluting” current shareholdings. To demonstrate by example…

  1. There are 4 current shareholders each with 25%.
  2. The Board proposes a share option scheme, increasing the available share capital of the company and granting key employees the option to purchase up to 20% of it.
  3. The 4 shareholders will be diluted from 25/100, to 25/125 – i.e. 20%.

To convince an existing shareholder to dilute his percentage shareholding, the Board will need a plan showing that either (i) failing to issue the option shares will have an adverse impact on the Company’s value; or (ii) that issuing the option shares is likely to materially increase the company’s value.

An EMI share option scheme is a tax-led procedure which must comply with current rules. The proposed option to be granted could be a one-off, or there could be an agreed scheme under which options are granted from time to time as determined by the trustees of that scheme.

The maximum value of qualifying EMI share options that may be given to any one employee is £250,000. Also, a company may not grant options worth more than £3 million in shares. Any options granted must be capable of being exercised within ten years of the date of grant.

The process for an employee offered EMI

The employee will be notified by the Board of their being granted an option, along with the applicable terms.

The option will (in nearly all cases) be a right to buy shares in the company at a value agreed by the Board with HMRC. That value will be heavily discounted against a comparable pro rata percentage of existing shares taken at commercial value.

Subject to the EMI scheme rules, the employee will become entitled to buy those option shares, but the purpose of establishing the EMI scheme may have included a planned exit/sale. This means that the option may become exercisable immediately before all other existing issued shares are sold; in such a case, the option holder exercises his right to buy the shares at the discounted price and immediately sell those option shares at the agreed overall share-sale price. The option-holder receives the profit, usually without having to fund the initial cost. The profit will then be subject to CGT.

If the employee leaves the company, the EMI rules may determine that the option lapses. The grant of a valuable share option is then considered a cost-free (to the company) method of retaining key employees and discouraging them from seeking new jobs.

The tax implications of EMI share options

For the company

A corporation tax deduction may be available when EMI options are exercised. The deduction is equal to the gains that the option holders have made. That has an advantageous impact on the company’s balance sheet.

For non-option shareholders

The latent balance sheet benefit referred to above may result in the price-per-share increasing due to the uplift in balance-sheet value.

For the employee

A HMRC-approved EMI share options scheme will avoid the risk of any options granted to employees being treated as “benefits in kind”. There is no tax liability on the grant of the option.

Providing the grant price of the option has been agreed with HMRC to be an accepted market value of that heavily discounted minority percentage shareholding, no tax will arise on the exercise of the grant.

On disposal, capital gains tax applies. Entrepreneurs’ Relief should be available provided the options were granted at least 12 months prior to the subsequent sale.

Enquire for an initial no-fee discussion

EMI share option schemes are an effective tool in the armoury of a Board who wishes to incentivise key employees. Should you have any further questions or require assistance with implementing EMI, our Corporate team are happy to receive your enquiry. If you would like an initial ‘no fee’ discussion with our experienced solicitors, contact the team directly:

Or complete the form below:

Back to News

More News from David

Ensuring the best succession planning for your business

Table of Contents Options for business succession planningStock market listingThird party/market salesFamily dynastic successionManagement buy-outs (MBOs)BenefitsDisadvantagesEmployee trust buy-outs (ETBOs)Winding up/solvent ...

Read More
Understanding corporate finance law

Table of Contents Loans from the bankDebenturesNegative Pledge and additional lendersPersonal GuaranteesThe obligation of a personal guarantorEnquire for an initial ...

Read More
Selling your business – Is it the right next step?

Table of Contents Business Review – What is right for your business?Option 1: Finance to grow your businessThe pros and ...

Read More
Video: Business Legal Advice from our corporate team

Table of Contents Watch our Business Legal Advice videoTrusted legal adviceMore advice from DavidDo you need help improving your business? ...

Read More
How to maximise your company’s share value, part 2 – Share Valuation

It’s time to consider the value of your shares in the Company you (or your family) have helped to create, ...

Read More
How to maximise your company’s share value, part 1 – Tax on Sales and ER

Table of Contents What is ER?How do I qualify?The company must…The shareholders must… As your business develops and you decide ...

Read More
Connect with Astle Paterson


Book an Appointment
Book an appointment
Burton on Trent Uttoxeter
Astle Paterson Accreditations

Business & Commercial   •   Conveyancing   •   Family   •   Litigation   •   Wills, Inheritance Tax & Probate   •   Employment